‘Always and Everywhere’...Again

Independent Gay Forum  Sep 16 09

by John CorvinoFirst published at 365gay.com on September 14, 2009

Last week I wrote about marriage-equality opponents' "Always and Everywhere" argument—the claim that since marriage has "always" been heterosexual, we ought not to tinker with it now.

In response, a prominent same-sex marriage opponent e-mailed me to explain what was "logically and philosophically wrong" with my critique. In particular, she argued that my claim that "each new same-sex marriage is a living counterexample to it" fails, because it misunderstands the rationale behind "always and everywhere. Full story...

Bookmark and Share

Have your say - be the first to comment

Please login to post a comment


Login


More stories from independent gay forum »

A Window Slams Shut

Independent Gay Forum  6 days ago

by Jennifer VanascoFirst published in the Chicago Free Press, November 18, 2009

I came out in the 1990s at the tail of the glory days of gay culture.

Why Approval Matters

Independent Gay Forum  Nov 17 09

by John CorvinoFirst published at 365gay.com on November 13, 2009

It’s November, which means bookstores have next year’s calendars on display.

Maine, Detroit, and the Closet

Independent Gay Forum  Nov 10 09

by John CorvinoFirst published at 365gay.com on November 7, 2009

When I was a “fag” on the junior high playground, getting punched hurt even when I saw it coming.

Taking Maine’s Measure

Independent Gay Forum  Nov 07 09

by James KirchickFirst published at Advocate.com on November 5, 2009

Maybe it was the cold weather.

Open—But Invisible

Independent Gay Forum  Nov 07 09

by Jennifer VanascoFirst published in the Chicago Free Press on November 5, 2009

No one can tell my girlfriend is gay.

What a Difference a Decade Makes

Independent Gay Forum  Oct 28 09

by Jennifer VanascoFirst published in the Chicago Free Press on October 28, 2009

It’s sometimes tough to measure progress, personal or political.

The Other Ballot Battles

Independent Gay Forum  Oct 22 09

by John CorvinoFirst published at 365gay.com on October 16, 2009

I’ve spent the last week traveling through rural Wisconsin for a series of diversity lectures at small technical colleges.

Opposite Color...Same Sex

Independent Gay Forum  Oct 21 09

by Jennifer VanascoFirst published in the Chicago Free Press on October 21, 2009

Let me tell you a story.

An Unbalanced Bill

Independent Gay Forum  Oct 21 09

by Richard E. Sincere Jr.First published in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, October 20, 2009

For more than a decade, liberal lawmakers have argued that federal "hate crimes" laws should be expanded to include sexual orientation among the categories that have been protected since the first such statute was enacted in the 1960s.

A New March, a New Movement

Independent Gay Forum  Oct 14 09

by Jennifer VanascoFirst published in the Chicago Free Press on October 14, 2009

The Equality March was a success.

Most read today »

Most read this week »

What's New on QueensSpeech Gay News